Fighting for Faith and Freedom
Each year on June 22nd we celebrate the feast days of two notable Catholic saints and martyrs: Saint Thomas More and Saint John Fisher. It’s fitting that these two men have the same feast day, because they were both Englishmen martyred within two weeks of each other, for the same cause (religious freedom), on the same occasion (defending the sanctity of marriage and Papal authority against State usurpation), and at the hands of the same man (King Henry VIII).
In addition to this, they were beatified together (by Pope Leo XIII in 1886) and canonized together (by Pius XI in 1935). Through the centuries they stand together—one a layman and statesman, the other a priest and bishop—as models and heroes of religious freedom against encroaching government power.
Sir Thomas More, Statesman and Saint
Saint Thomas More died a martyrs death at the hands of England’s infamous King Henry VIII. Although once friends, St. Thomas More fell into disfavor with the King when he refused to compromise his conscience and his faith for the sake of friendship, career, wealth, and worldly prestige.
According to Pope John Paul II’s Apostolic Letter on St. Thomas More, More was “Highly esteemed by everyone for his unfailing moral integrity, sharpness of mind, his open and humorous character, and his extraordinary learning.” He served in parliament, on the King’s council, as a diplomat, and in many other notable positions in public administration. He was also first and foremost a faithful Catholic, a loving husband, and devoted father.
St. Thomas More was eventually promoted by King Henry VIII himself to the high office of Lord Chancellor. He resigned from this post when the king, in open defiance of Church teaching, desired to divorce his wife in order to marry another woman, and declare himself sovereign of the Church in England to make it happen. Thomas More refused to accept or condone King Henry’s unconscionable actions, choosing to resign from his high position rather than be complicit in this great evil.
After trying unsuccessfully to persuade his former friend to his side, King Henry VIII imprisoned Sir Thomas More in the Tower of London where he was eventually condemned and beheaded. At his trial, Thomas More testified boldly for Church autonomy over the state, for the authority of the Pope as head of the Church, and for the indissolubility of marriage in the eyes of God–even when he knew he would die for it. St. Thomas More refused to undermine his Catholic faith and died a martyrs death upholding the truth–with integrity and without compromise.
In October of 2000, after many petitions, Pope John Paul II published this apostolic letter on Thomas More in order to name him the patron saint of statesman and politicians, “Given his inflexible firmness in rejecting any compromise with his own conscience”, forever giving those who serve the state a model of unwavering integrity and virtue in the face of enormous political pressure. He was martyred on July 6, 1535, just two weeks after John Fisher’s own martyrdom.
Sir John Fisher, Bishop and Saint
Like St. Thomas More, St. John Fisher also had a personal connection with King Henry VIII, as a friend of the royal family and once entrusted as his tutor. Sir John Fisher was known for being a man of great learning and great faith, having been appointed a lifetime seat as the Chancellor of Cambridge University and Bishop of Rochester.
Bishop John Fisher fell into disfavor with King Henry VIII when he supported the Queen, Catherine of Aragon, against the unlawful divorce the King sought to obtain from her. In defense of the Queen, he declared that he was willing to die to uphold the integrity of marriage. He also warned parliament of the King’s encroaching power over the English Church in disregard of Papal authority.
The King never forgave him for this defiance. Despite secret attempts on his life, Fisher preached against divorce from the pulpit at the same time Sir Thomas More, likewise in protest of the King’s actions, resigned from his high office. For his rebelliousness to the King, or rather, for his faithfulness to the Church, John Fisher was imprisoned multiple times. One of these arrests came about shortly after the King secretly married Anne Boleyn, and just ahead of an official announcement of his divorce from the Queen and Boleyn’s subsequent coronation. After the danger of his outspokenness passed, Fisher was released from prison.
Not long after this, parliament passed an act that would officially recognize the marriage of King Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn under pain of treason for those who refused to follow suit. Fisher refused to comply with this unjust law, and was once again imprisoned in the Tower of London, this time for good. While imprisoned the Pope made him a Cardinal, but the King rejected the appointment.
Sir John Fisher died on this day, June 22, in 1535 (just two weeks before Sir Thomas More). The charge against him was treason, both for refusing to recognize King Henry VIII as sovereign of the Church in England, and for refusing to recognize his preferred marriage as valid.
At the time of his impending death, the people of England rightly saw a strong resemblance between John Fisher’s martyrdom and that of St. John the Baptist, who was also beheaded for speaking out against a ruler’s unlawful divorce and remarriage. Because of this strong resemblance, King Henry VIII was afraid to let Fisher live until the feast day of John the Baptist which was coming up on June 24, and had him killed two days before. The irony is that John Fisher was due to be hanged, drawn, and quartered, but because the King hastened his death ahead of the feast day, he was beheaded instead . . . just like John the Baptist after all.
Saints for All Times
Saint John Fisher and Saint Thomas More stood up to a powerful, intelligent, and charismatic King when the King went too far. King Henry VIII became corrupt when he lusted after women and power, eventually having six wives, separating the Church of England from Rome, declaring himself its head, and killing those who stood in his way. Meanwhile, these evil actions on the part of a King-turned-tyrant was an opportunity for two holy and just men to earn the eternal crowns of martyrdom and sainthood.