At the Last Supper, Peter and Judas were sitting in the same room. They heard the same words from Christ, shared in the same moment, and within hours, both would fail Him in profound ways. One would deny Him three times, and the other would hand Him over. From the outside, their sins are different, but the more revealing part of the story is not what they did, but what they did afterward.
Peter’s failure is deeply human. He had promised loyalty, even to death, and yet when confronted, he denied even knowing Christ. When he realized what he had done, he wept. There is no attempt to justify himself, no attempt to explain it away. His sorrow is real, and it is painful. But it does not lead him away from Christ. It leaves him open. Even in his failure, he remains within reach of mercy.
Judas also experiences something after his betrayal. Scripture tells us that he returned the silver and admitted that he had sinned. But his sorrow takes a different direction. Instead of turning back toward Christ, he turns inward. What he feels does not lead him to hope, but to despair. The difference between the two is not that one sinned and the other did not, but that one trusted in mercy and the other did not.
There is something in this that applies directly to us. At some level, we should feel sorrow and be ashamed of our sins. It would be strange if we did not feel some discomfort in recognizing that we have turned away from God. But there is a kind of shame that does not lead us back to Him. It settles in, grows, and eventually keeps us from bringing our sins to God at all. This kind of “undue shame” leads us to hide from God rather than allow Him to heal what we have done.
At that point, something subtle has shifted. We are no longer simply sorry. We begin to believe, even if we would not say it outright, that what we have done is beyond forgiveness. That our sin is somehow greater than God’s mercy. But as the tradition reminds us, this is not humility. It is a hidden form of pride. To believe that our actions can outweigh the Cross is to place ourselves above the very mercy we claim to need.
Peter does not do this. He does not deny his sin, but he also does not deny Christ’s mercy. Judas, for reasons we can only partially understand, steps outside of it. That is the real tragedy of his story. Mercy was not withheld from him. It was refused.
That is where this becomes more than a reflection on two figures from the Gospel. It becomes a question for us. Most of us will never betray Christ in the way Judas did, but we do experience the same hesitation, the same temptation to hold something back. There are moments when it feels easier to carry a sin ourselves than to bring it honestly before God. There are moments when we delay, avoid, or quietly convince ourselves that we will deal with it later.
But the pattern remains the same. Both men failed—both experienced sorrow. The difference came in what they did next. One returned, even in weakness. The other did not.
The Sacrament of Confession is the remedy for our sins. Oftentimes, we forget the incredible beauty and peace we receive when we experience God's mercy. How to Make a Good Confession is a wonderful book that explores the beauty of confession. Purchase your copy today at The Catholic Company!
