Why Michelangelo regretted signing the Pietà (and why we can all relate)

Michelangelo went on to create David. The ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. The Last Judgment. And many more incredibly stunning works of art. None of them bears his carved signature.

Michelangelo Pieta

It is one of the most famous sculptures in the world. The Pietà. Mary holding the broken, deceased body of her Son. Serene. Almost impossibly tender.

And if you look closely, across the sash that runs over Our Lady’s chest, you will see something unusual. A signature.

MICHAELA[N]GELUS BONAROTUS FLORENTINUS FACIEBAT. “Michelangelo Buonarroti, the Florentine, made this.”

It is the only work he ever signed.

Michelangelo was in his early twenties when he carved the Pietà. When it was placed in Old St. Peter’s Basilica around the year 1500, people gathered around it in awe. According to his biographer Giorgio Vasari, Michelangelo once overheard visitors attributing the sculpture to another artist. He said nothing at the time. But that night, he returned to the basilica with his tools and carved his name boldly into the marble.

He wanted it known that he had made this.

It is not hard to understand. He was young. He was brilliant. He had created something extraordinary. And he was human.

Tradition holds that he later regretted signing it. Whether or not we can document the interior struggle, one thing is certain: he never signed another sculpture again. We cannot know exactly what he felt afterward. 

The Church has always understood that artistic genius is a gift, not a possession. Scripture reminds us that even our skills come from God. We shape what He has made. We build with what He first placed into existence. Michelangelo carved marble that God formed in the depths of the earth. He sculpted a mystery that God revealed. The Pietà is not ultimately about Michelangelo. It is about Christ and His Mother.

The beautiful words from Scripture echo in this marble piece: “He emptied himself” (Philippians 2:7.) 

And there, across her sash, is a young artist who briefly grasped for recognition. Then stopped.

How many of us have done the same? Wanted credit a little too quickly. Felt overlooked and quietly corrected it. Signed our name more boldly than we needed to.

Could this be an indication of the way grace often works? Not with public drama, but with interior refinement? We will never really know.

Michelangelo went on to create David. The ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. The Last Judgment. And many more incredibly stunning works of art. None of them bears his carved signature. While we will never know the reason for sure, we will continue to be awed by the Pieta; it takes our breath away. 

You can look on this beloved statue in your own home with the White Pieta Statue 8".I deal for display during Lent or anytime, it serves as a prompt for prayer and reflection.

Order yours today at The Catholic Company! 

 

You may also like

Sale price$62.95
Sold out

Reading next

Faint monochrome image of a bearded man’s face with closed eyes, resembling the Shroud of Turin’s sacred relic impression.